CSE91 - Fall 2007

Project report review form

Your team's project title:
Reviewed team's project title:
  1. PURPOSE
    • Are the subject and the objectives (motivation, problem statement, goals, etc.) of the project clear?
    • Has the project deviated substantially from the original proposal?
    • What are your suggestions for improvement?
  2. STRUCTURE
    • Is the content well-organized, according to clear partitions?
    • What are your suggestions for improvement?
  3. TECHNICAL CONTENT
    • Does the report describe the project (methods, results, data/outcomes) in sufficient detail?
    • In what ways is it too detailed? In what ways is it too superficial?
    • What technical descriptions or discussion do you feel is missing?
  4. PRESENTATION
    • Does the report present the project effectively?
    • Is the available space (page budget) used well?
    • Where could presentation of data (tables, charts, graphs etc.) or images could be improved?
    • Is the writing clear and concise?
    • Are there language problems (grammar, syntax, terminology, colloquialisms, etc.)?
  5. GOALS FOR FINAL PRESENTATION
    • What should the team make sure to include in their final report?
    • What content would help make the final presentation (PPT, 10-minute talk) as engaging and effective as possible?